Talk:Forgetting Sarah Marshall

Cast Pages
This seems to present a gray area, following the recent discussion at Category talk:Celebrities, and I'm not sure how to proceed (I haven't actually seen the film, by the way, just read the production notes clarifying the Creature Shop aspect). Our earlier consensus was that people count as Creature Shop actors and get pages if they appeared in a film (either from the Jim Henson Company or with the Creature Shop as an effects house) with physical creatures, costuming or prosthetics, or digital creatures, regardless of how much of a given actor's screentime was shared with the Creature Shop effects. For this, the Creature Shop provided physical puppets, but they're not intended as breathing, flesh and blood creatures within the film's narrative. They're puppets used in a puppet show by the main character. Should that make a difference? If it does to others, my own gut feeling would be pages for Jason Segel (who apparently has been signed to script a new Muppet Movie anyway) and Bill Hader, who actually operated the Creature Shop-made puppets and for the other main stars (Kristen Bell and Mila Kunis, who are caricatured as the puppets anyway, Russell Brand) but not the supporting players, cameos, and bit actors who have no other relevance (Jonah Hill, Paul Rudd, etc.) I'm not committed either way, though. What do other people think? -- Andrew Leal (talk ) 00:19, 20 April 2008 (UTC)