Recycled puppets

Note: This list does not include Anything Muppets, Whatnots, or Unisaurs, who are endlessly recycled as different characters.


 * Shakey Sanchez and Princess Lulabelle
 * Ingrid, Frieda, Juliet, and Mona Monster
 * King Goshposh and King Rupert the Second
 * Taminella Grinderfall and Tommy
 * Prime Minister and Fred
 * Yorick and Palace Guard
 * Blustering Bellowpane Monster and Singalotti
 * The Beast and Rude Dude
 * Elmo and Baby Monster
 * Lyle the Dog, Colonel Claghound, and All-Dog Network Announcer
 * Ballerina Pig and Sweetums Pig
 * Grouch Ice Cream Customer and Sharon Groan
 * Jacques Roach and Yves St. La Roache
 * Hillary the Owl and Timmy the Owl
 * Featherstone and The Queen
 * Winny the Cafeteria Bird and Claudia Bird
 * Joe the Armadillo and Annette
 * Mad Dog and Bowser
 * Bugsy Them and Bruno
 * Poison Cackler and Jo Beth Gardehoo
 * Boo Monster and Flunky
 * Waldorf and P. Fenton Cosgrove
 * Big Head, Opera Singer (Sesame Street), and The Blimp
 * Roxie Marie and Griotte
 * Narf and Yoyo
 * Carina the Ballerina and Olive
 * Big Mary Louise and Grump
 * H. Ross Parrot and Poco Loco