Recycled puppets

Note: This list does not include Anything Muppets, Whatnots, or Unisaurs, who are endlessly recycled as different characters.
 * See also: Puppets Recycled in Puppet Up!


 * Shakey Sanchez and Princess Lulabelle
 * Lenny the Lizard and Wendell Wizard
 * Beautiful Day Monster and Crown-Grabber
 * Big Bad Wolf and Jackman Wolf
 * Maurice Monster, Kermit the Gorf, and Elmo Mondiporg
 * Ingrid, Frieda, Juliet, and Mona Monster
 * King Goshposh and King Rupert the Second
 * Taminella Grinderfall and Tommy
 * Prime Minister, Fred, and mad scientist from Shrinkenstein
 * Earl and Flaggerdragon
 * Anthony and Professor Hugh Mungous
 * Yorick and Palace Guard
 * Blustering Bellowpane Monster and Singalotti
 * The Beast and Rude Dude
 * Elmo and Baby Monster
 * Lyle the Dog, Colonel Claghound, and All-Dog Network Announcer
 * Ballerina Pig and Sweetums Pig
 * Grouch Ice Cream Customer and Sharon Groan
 * Jacques Roach and Yves St. La Roache
 * Hillary the Owl and Timothy the Owl
 * Featherstone and The Queen
 * Winny the Cafeteria Bird and Claudia Bird
 * Dooley the Armadillo, Annette and Joe the Armadillo
 * Mad Dog and Bowser
 * Bugsy Them and Bruno
 * Bubba the Bartender and Scratch McCollie
 * Pavlov the Pug Dog and Piddles
 * Poison Cackler and Jo Beth Garfdoohoo
 * Big Mean Carl, Carla the Big Mean Mom, Chairman Budget, and The Glox
 * Boo Monster and Flunky
 * Tug Monster and Do Re Mi Monster
 * Waldorf and P. Fenton Cosgrove
 * Statler and Astoria
 * Snarl and Gonzo
 * Snivelly and Droop
 * Big Head, Opera Singer (Sesame Street), and The Blimp
 * Clarissa, Loni Dunne, and Denise
 * Roxie Marie and Griotte
 * Narf and Yoyo
 * Karina the Ballerina and Olive
 * Mary Louise and Grump
 * H. Ross Parrot and Poco Loco
 * Food and Zsa Zsa Porkmustard
 * Mulch and Composta Heap
 * Carter and Faversham
 * The Christmas Turkey and Mr. Warble
 * Wolfram Wolf and Piratenkapitän Wolfdietrich Säbelmeier
 * Kenner Gooney Bird, Little Bird, Turbo Theo, and Mats
 * Flower-Eating Monster and Flatcap Frankie
 * Luncheon Counter Monster and Coach Gruesome
 * Miss Kitty and Thudge McGerk
 * Alfonso D'Bruzzo and Polly Wanna Cracker
 * Leapovitch the Frog and Mavis the Frog
 * Kasey the Kangaroo and Sheila the Kangaroo
 * Chuck the Lion, Lazlo the Lion, and Malcolm the Lion
 * Lenny the Gorilla, Mary the Gorilla, and Gilda the Gorilla
 * Paul the Pelican and Carol Croon
 * Big V and Shrinkenstein
 * Big Old Bullfrog and Bufo the Toad
 * Ms. Henrietta Vanderpeen and Lydia the Ostrich
 * Randall the Zebra and Ice Station Zebra
 * Lois and Milton the Blue-Footed Booby
 * Watson and Moe Cocker
 * Zondra and Darci
 * Vicki and Scary Mary
 * Socks the Cat and Frecklehead
 * Lindbergh and Clive the Kiwi
 * Leon and Gingrich the Newt
 * Snook and Stinky the Skunk
 * Shelley Turtle and Seymour