In the video it is revealed that Abby spends part of her time living with her daddy at his house and part of her time living with her mommy at her house. Although Abby's parents are no longer married and live in different houses, Abby learns that they both still love her.
Abby shows Elmo, Rosita and Gordon a drawing of her daddy and their house; and while Abby's father is not directly shown in the video, his green hands are shown in a point-of-view shot tucking Abby into bed while Abby sings a song about her family situation.
In a 2019 online video produced for Sesame Street in Communities, when Abby's family (now including step-relatives Rudy and Freddy) are about to head to a baseball game, Abby laments her father's absence, mentioning that he loves baseball. Abby's mom consoles her and assures her that her dad will continue to be a big part of her life.
- Freddy, Abby Cadabby's stepfather