|Music by||Kathryn Raio-Rende and JP Rende|
|Lyrics by||Christine Ferraro|
|Publisher|| Easy Reader Music|
Sesame Street Inc.
"Come Back Cookie" is a Sesame Street song from the home video, Elmo's Music Magic. While most of the framing footage is taken from episode 4220, this song is one of the few new scenes created for the video and the only new composition for it.
While using Abby Cadabby's wand to make people sing, Elmo wishes to make someone sing fast and slow. He spots an unsuspecting Cookie Monster nearby and sends the spell his way. Cookie begins singing about eating his cookie, which comes alive, forcing Cookie to chase it and sing. As they run, Elmo changes the speed of their song.