In this show, Elmo and the gang, along with an artist named Professor Art, go into a coloring book and make drawings. Meanwhile, many different things turn from their original color to white. Among these is Oscar the Grouch, who suddenly turns nicer when he's white. Eventually, they learn that the colors were taken by a polar bear who wants to be these colors.
- Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Telly Monster, Rosita, Bert, Ernie, Count Von Count, Prairie Dawn, Oscar the Grouch, Baby Bear, Professor Art, Blanche the Polar Bear, The Palettes
note:*Telly recieved more stage time in this show due to his absence in "123 Imagine!," the previous year. The Zoe costume switched with the Blanche costume in the 2004 version of the show. Proffesor Art has recieved a less scarier look for the 2004 opening tour(notice the beard in the original?).