Participation in the Muppet Wiki Forums requires a full understanding of the Rules and Etiquette.
For the page on the 1996/2009 Sesame Street Live show 1-2-3 Imagine!, we have four different sources that each have different lists for the songs.
- In 2011, Shane added a list of tracks (diff)
- In 2022, Tony added a different list (diff)
- The soundtrack album has a different list
- On the Sesame Street Live wiki, there's a fourth list
For example, there's either one or two songs about hot/cold:
- SSL wiki: "Hot, Hot, Hot" and "Steam Heat"
- Soundtrack: "Hot, Hot, Hot"
- Shane: "Steam Heat"
- Tony: "Hot, It's Not! Antarctica"
For the beach section:
- SSL wiki: "Aloha", "Yellow Bird', "Do the Hula", "Surfin' Safari"
- Soundtrack: "Yellow Bird", "Surfin' Safari"
- Shane: "Aloha", "Yellow Bird", "Do the Hula", "Wipe Out", "Surfin' Safari"
- Tony: "Hurry-Up Hula", "Sesame Surfin' Safari"
The soundtrack and the SSL wiki mostly match, but the soundtrack omits some of the tracks (which is unsurprising).
Shane's list has songs that the others don't, possibly including some instrumentals: "Sesame Street Theme", "Rubber Duckie", "Wipe Out", "Elmo's Song", "Kazoo Fanfare", "The Mask Dance", "Camp Wanna-Go-Home", "Imagine with Me", "La Pinata (Dale, Dale)" and three extra songs during the Camp Medley ("Ride of the Valkyries", "La Raspa", "When the Saints Go Marchin' In")
Tony's list appears to be the outlier, with five titles that aren't used in the other lists: "Mail Call" (possibly "1-2-3 Imagine Theme"), "Bottom of the Sea Jamboree" (everyone else calls this "At the Codfish Ball"), "Hurry-Up Hula" (see above), and "Hot, It's Not! Antarctica" (see above), "Mardi Gras Parade" (everyone else calls this "Big Bird's Big Parade")
I would like to merge these into a single canonical list. My current thought is to use the SSL wiki/soundtrack as the base, plus the extra songs that Shane included (possibly marking some as instrumentals, if Shane agrees). That would eliminate Tony's list, as the outlier.
Shane and Tony, what do you think? —Danny 
(talk) 18:10, 15 March 2023 (UTC)
- I have the program still from when I went to see this in 2002, so that's my source for the additions I made. - Shane (talk) 18:24, 15 March 2023 (UTC)