|PERFORMER||Fran Brill 2006-2015|
|Stephanie D'Abruzzo 2016-present|
In the latter, she takes her toaster to the Fix-It Shop for repair, for the Toast Lovers' Society's luncheon. She desperately needs it fixed, "or I'm toast!" When it takes a while to be repaired, she partakes in "The Toast Lovers' Participatory Popping Game", which is pretending you're a piece of toast in a toaster. The waiting pays off and the toaster is ready.
- Sesame Street
- Sesame Street's 50th Anniversary Celebration
- The Not-Too-Late Show with Elmo episode 105