Muppet Wiki
Written by Jeff Moss

"Put a Cookie in My Mouth" is a Sesame Street party game based on "Pin the Tail on the Donkey". Cookie Monster sings a song about how to play the game. First, the players at home put a picture of Cookie Monster on the wall. Then each person, while wearing a blindfold, tries to put a cookie in Cookie Monster's mouth. Cookie Monster remarks on the various body parts that aren't his mouth. He says not to put a cookie on his toe or shoulder, or in his eye, because that will make him cry. He also says not to put it in his ear, because then he can't hear, or in his paw, because "that's against the law".