During the week at camp, Rusty was reluctant to participate in activities and had to be urged many times by Mickey and Cabin 10 to do things like wake up or make his bed. Because of this, at the end of the week he was given the Good Sport award for "doing a lot of things he really didn't want to do." It was also revealed at the end of the same episode that Rusty lives around the corner from Sesame Street and that his full name is Russel Edmund Windgate III. Rusty returns in Episode 1713.
He also appeared at the 1982 Daytime Emmy Awards, performing a musical number with the human and Muppet cast.