PERFORMER Alice Dinnean DEBUT 1994 Scary Mary appeared in a series of Muppet Time segments on Nickelodeon. Scary Mary claims to be the best scarer in the whole wide world. One of her frequent victims is her cat, Frecklehead. The puppet used for Scary Mary was a modified version of Vicki, from The Jim Henson Hour. Retrieved from "https://muppet.fandom.com/wiki/Scary_Mary?oldid=1204468" Categories: The Muppets Characters Muppet Characters Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.