The Genie of the Toothpaste appears in a Sesame Street insert, offering Cookie Monster three wishes in the story of "The Monster's Three Wishes." In this sketch, he was played by Jim Henson. (First: Episode 0634)
Jerry Nelson performed the Genie in his subsequent appearances. He appears in a Season 8 Sesame Street News Flash sketch with Aladdin. He was also featured in the street stories for Episode 2629, where he appears to Telly Monster in a dream as "The Genie of the Cookie Tin," and Episode 4025, again serving as Aladdin's genie.