The Genie of the Toothpaste appears in a Sesame Street insert, offering Cookie Monster three wishes in the story of "The Monster's Three Wishes." In this sketch, he was played by Jim Henson. (First: Episode 0634)
The Genie reappears in a Season 8 Sesame Street News Flash sketch with Aladdin, where he was played by Jerry Nelson. He also appears in Episode 2629 as "The Genie of the Cookie Tin", played again by Nelson, serving as an aide to Telly Monster in his dream. He appears again as Aladdin's genie in Episode 4025, played by Nelson once more.