Grover has a new method of remembering orders: he makes up a poem to remember what is ordered, and who ordered it. Mr. Johnson orders a cheeseburger with French fries and a pickle, which Grover interprets as "Round and tasty on a bun, pickles, French fries, yum, yum, yum!" He also describes Johnson as "In a hurry to be fed, beady eyes and big blue head!." Grover's method proves flawed, however, as he brings Mr. Johnson a grapefruit on a bun. Grover eventually realizes his mistake, but declines to fix it, as it is his lunch break, and he heads out for his own cheeseburger.
This sketch was incorporated into the plot of Episode 2696, where an angry Mr. Johnson comes to Hooper's Store to order a cheeseburger, but he gets a call from Grover to come back, promising to provide better service. Afterwards, Mr. Johnson returns to Hooper's for the cheeseburger, but Gina reveals she sold it to another customer: Grover!