Kal Penn has opened Kal's Scrumptious Soups, and for a change, Grover is the one being served. Grover orders one small, cold soup. When his soup arrives, Grover changes his mind, instead opting for the opposite: hot soup. Then, when his small, hot soup arrives, he once again opts for the opposite: large soup. When that arrives, Grover changes his mind once more, deciding the soup is too wet and requesting the opposite. Kal freaks out at the request for dry soup and leaves for a vacation, leaving Mr. Johnson with a new, unfortunate server.
