Whatnots are blank Muppet heads, onto which facial features, bodies, and clothes are added to make any kind of character in the Muppet Show universe. A similar group of Muppets known as Anything Muppets appear on Sesame Street.
The concept of a blank-faced puppet with interchangeble facial features and ever changing personalities sees its origin with the character of The Southern Colonel, as demostrated in the "A Change of Face" routine performed on several occasions in variety shows during the 1960s. The Southern Colonel puppet would also be used during the first season of Sesame Street assuming the personality of characters such as Jack and Granny Fanny Nesselrode.
A new batch of skin-toned Whatnots would be introduced in The Great Santa Claus Switch and used as patterns for the Elves characters. These puppets would later see other uses during the early 1970s: the peasants in The Frog Prince and the human prisoners from the "Return to Beneath the Planet of the Pigs" from The Muppet Show: Sex and Violence as well as for individual characters such as Wally and Leo.
In The Muppet Show, many varieties of Whatnots would be introduced. In the first two seasons, the Whatnots were mostly shaped like Fraggles. Later in the series, more humanoid Whatnots were added, often with sculpted noses. Notable recurring characters made from Whatnots include Lew Zealand, Marvin Suggs, and Bobby Benson.
Other new Whatnot patterns would be seen in following Muppet productions and used both as "utility" Muppets and recurring characters: Muppets Tonight features Whatnot characters such as Zippity Zap and Bill the Bubble Guy, the Muppet Meeting Films had Franklin and Shirley, and From the Balcony had Larry and Oliver.
In 1993, Playskool released a series of toy Muppet Workshop Puppet Kits based on the concept of Whatnot Muppets.
In 2008, FAO Schwarz in New York City opened The Muppet Whatnot Workshop, an interactive puppet creation display that remained in operation until 2015. For promotion of the workshop, the Muppets (led by the Whatnots) took over the Today Show on November 13, 2008.