The 2018 Sesame Street special When You Wish Upon a Pickle was originally announced to be released on DVD and digital by Shout! Factory on June 2, 2020. The video was released on digital platforms on June 2, but a physical release never occurred.
Following the main feature, the release contains about a half hour of magic-related street stories and segments, including:
- The cold open for Episode 4623
- Magic Spell street story
- "Letter of the Day - M"
- "Just Like Magic"
- Wand Magic with Abby
- Everyday Magic street story
- Pick an 8, Any 8 with Chris and Grover
DVD bonus content was to include a previous video release, Elmo's Magic Numbers.